The United States has always described itself through its values. They show up in the founding documents, in the speeches, in the arguments people have at dinner tables. In my experience, a country's values are easiest to see not in its mottos but in its policies — in what a government actually does when it has the power to act. So let's look at what's happening under the current administration, in Trump's second term, and ask what these six values tell us about American identity right now, at home and abroad.
I want to look at six values that seem to define the United States under its current administration, and think through how each one lands differently depending on where you're standing.
American sovereignty
The first value is sovereignty. The Trump administration's policies emphasize the United States' right to self-determination and control over its borders, economy, and policies.
You can see it in stricter immigration laws, and in withdrawal from international agreements like the Paris Climate Accord and the World Health Organization. Put together, these moves mark a return to prioritizing national interests over global obligations.
How it affects people
- In the U.S.: For many Americans, this focus on sovereignty reinforces a sense of national pride and security. For immigrants and marginalized groups, though, it's a source of uncertainty and fear.
- Globally: Sovereignty as a value signals a shift away from global cooperation, and that has consequences for issues like climate change and public health. Nations that have relied on American leadership may feel abandoned. Others might follow the same isolationist path.
Economic protectionism
The second value is economic protectionism. Policies like tariffs on foreign goods, paired with incentives for domestic production, reflect a belief in prioritizing American workers and businesses.
How it affects people
- In the U.S.: This value resonates with workers in industries like manufacturing and energy. It also raises consumer costs and complicates international trade relationships — both are true at once.
- Globally: Countries that export goods to the U.S. may face economic hardship, which strains alliances and can spark trade wars. Developing nations may struggle to compete in a system built around American dominance.
Freedom of speech
Freedom of speech has seen renewed emphasis, with efforts to reduce censorship gaining momentum. Meta made a similar move in January 2025, ending its third-party fact-checking program and loosening several content policies in the name of "free expression" — a change announced just before Trump took office, though clearly in step with the administration's stance on open discourse.
Some on the far left fear being targeted. I think that's worth taking seriously, and I'd also say freedom and respect need to coexist for this value to mean much. Trump's administration, despite divisive rhetoric, is not persecuting individuals, nor does it match the extremist caricature some portray. Overreactions in the media have fueled division. But shared values like free speech still offer a path to unity, if we let them.
How it affects people
- In the U.S.: Americans are encouraged to voice opinions freely, which makes for vibrant — if sometimes contentious — debate. The harder part is keeping that dialogue respectful.
- Globally: Freedom of speech inspires other nations to reconsider restrictions on expression. Without balance, though, it risks amplifying divisive voices, which is why responsible communication matters as much as the freedom itself.
Merit-based equality
The administration has championed merit-based systems, phasing out programs focused on diversity, equity, and inclusion. The stated goal is to reward individual achievement over group identity.
How it affects people
- In the U.S.: Advocates argue this levels the playing field. Critics worry it erases the systemic challenges minorities face, which could widen social and economic gaps rather than close them.
- Globally: The retreat from diversity-focused policies sends a signal to other nations. It could encourage similar shifts elsewhere, reducing the emphasis on equity and inclusion more broadly.
Traditionalism
Traditionalism has re-emerged as a cornerstone value, with an emphasis on historical norms and structures. Policies like redefining gender categories and reinstating the federal death penalty reflect this stance.
How it affects people
- In the U.S.: Traditionalism appeals to those who see these measures as preserving moral and cultural stability. It alienates others, particularly LGBTQ+ individuals and activists pushing for progress and inclusion.
- Globally: This emphasis may embolden conservative movements elsewhere in the world. It could just as easily deepen the divide between progressive and traditionalist nations.
Self-reliance
Self-reliance runs through many of the administration's policies. Encouraging energy independence and reducing reliance on foreign goods are both framed as a path to resilience and greatness.
How it affects people
- In the U.S.: For individuals and businesses, this reinforces the value of hard work and independence. Those who depend on social programs or international trade may feel left behind by it.
- Globally: Nations that have historically depended on U.S. aid or partnerships may face real challenges here. Some may treat it as a prompt to build their own self-reliance instead.
How do these values reflect the American identity?
At their core, these values reflect a desire for control, security, and self-determination. They point to a nation grappling with change, trying to work out its place in a fast-evolving world.
But values are never static. They're lived. They're tested. They evolve.
The United States remains, in my view, a place of real possibility — even in moments of division. Sovereignty, protectionism, free speech, merit, tradition, and self-reliance may dominate the conversation today, but I'd argue the deeper American spirit is found in balancing these with openness, compassion, and progress.
How can the U.S. lead by example?
Leadership isn't about isolation. It's about inspiration. By holding onto core values that reflect integrity and transparency, America can continue to be a guiding light — that's the standard I'd hold it to, anyway.
For individuals, that means advocating for values that unite rather than divide. For leaders, it means recognizing how interconnected our world has become, and making choices that serve both the U.S. and humanity more broadly.
Why hope matters now more than ever
Hope isn't passive. It's a force for action.
The United States is at a crossroads. Reflecting on these core values gives Americans a chance to shape a future that honors the best of them — a future where sovereignty doesn't rule out cooperation, where protectionism doesn't crowd out fairness, and where tradition sits alongside innovation rather than against it.
A nation's values are a mirror of its people. Together, they can choose to build a legacy of resilience, unity, and hope — one worthy of the land of the free and the home of the brave.
Discover your own core values
Take the free, research-backed Values App assessment — nine minutes, max.
Discover your values